home | news | screensaver | our stories | your stories | timelines

  
Power and passion index
 

Peter Charlton
Peter Charlton is The Courier-Mail's national affairs editor. He is a former associate editor and leader writer, and political editor in Canberra. He is also the author of State of Mind — Why Queensland is Different.
Ten best & worst decisions

When did Queensland get it right? When did we get it wrong? Peter Charlton picks the state's best and worst decisions.

Ten of the best

1 The decision by police minister Bill Gunn, right, in May 1987 to hold a royal commission into police corruption. The inquiry by Tony Fitzgerald, QC, did much to end decades of corruption.

2 Gunn's decision, on advice from Ian Callinan, QC — now High Court Justice Callinan — to appoint Fitzgerald to head the corruption inquiry.

3 Decisions by Queensland governments to concentrate on primary industries, including mining, at the expense of manufacturing, sparing Queensland much of the post-1983 pain of tariff reductions and loss of protection.

4 Abolition of death duties by the Bjelke-Petersen government in 1972. This had an enormous impact, producing a flight of capital from southern states; other states then followed suit. Death duties were a regressive taxation.

5 The Bjelke-Petersen government's support for "development". Although this was not without its costs, much of Queensland's prosperity has been underpinned by the efforts of foreign mining companies.

6 Demolition of the Belle Vue Hotel, left, in April 1979. Although this could be included in the "worst decisions" list, the furore caused the Bjelke-Petersen government to rethink its policies on conservation of old buildings.
The Belle Vue did not die in vain: its sacrifice saved Parliament House, the Mansions Building in George Street and many other beautiful buildings from the Victorian era.

7 Support for Gold Coast canal and waterway developments, right, pioneered by Sir Bruce Small. Despite gloomy prognostications, these estates have not become stagnant, mosquito-ridden backwaters but provide a comfortable lifestyle for many.
Picture: Tourism Queensland

8 The decision, more than 80 years ago, to consolidate the local councils of the Brisbane area into the Brisbane City Council. Unusual in Australia, this huge local authority has had its critics — and its necessarily uneasy relationships with state governments — but remains one of the most efficient administrations in Australia, mercifully free of the corruption that has plagued councils in other capital cities.

9 The electoral reforms of the late 1980s and early 1990s that removed a corrupt system abused by both Labor and Country/National parties over the years. The so-called zonal system made a mockery of "one vote-one value", encouraged arrogance in office and timidity in opposition and devalued the democratic process.

10 Enthusiastic support for World Expo 88 by the Queensland government. Expo convinced Queenslanders that it was possible to eat outside, enjoy the culture and cuisine of other countries and enjoy their city as never before. Before Expo, Brisbane was a big country town; after Expo, it never looked back.

Ten of the worst

                                               
   
opyright Queensland Newspapers Pty Ltd